Wednesday, March 4, 2015

Homeschoolers and College: Five Essentials

When my kids were little, preparing for college was just a worry in the back of my mind.  They would certainly go after they graduated from our homeschool, but until it got close I didn’t have to think about it, right?

Wrong!  Now that we're in our twenty-first year of homeschooling and have sent three kids off to college, I've formed some definite ideas about what it takes to succeed there.   Here are the five things I believe to be most essential to launching a young adult into the big world of college.  They are all things that must be built gradually, starting from a young age.

First: Spiritual Maturity
Does your child have a strong testimony of the gospel?  Does he have habits that will maintain his testimony in the absence of parental oversight?  Does he know the joy of service, in and out of the church?  We set an example for our children in all areas of our lives, and there are things best taught by deeds.  As we do our visiting teaching, as our children see us reading our scriptures and attending the temple, and as we share our feelings about these things with them in daily devotionals, they will have a firm foundation for their own spiritual growth. Temptations abound on LDS and non-LDS campuses alike.  “Testimony: Don’t Leave Home Without It.”

Second: Emotional Maturity
A large challenge when moving into young adulthood isn’t knowing what to do, but being able to make oneself do it.  Your teen knows she should eat vegetables, but with you not there to put them on her plate will they end up in her mouth?  She knows she shouldn’t sign up for a credit card unless she has a job (and probably not even then), but they were offering those free T-shirts!  She knows she shouldn’t get into a car with someone she doesn’t know, even if her roommate is, but it was cold and she didn’t want to walk home!  Impulsivity and lack of maturity cause freshmen to sometimes make decisions that they come to regret.
Does your child (especially if she’s shy) have the guts to go knock on her professor’s office door to seek help with a concept she doesn’t understand?  Does she have the time-management skills to pace herself with big papers and assignments?  Can she make herself go sit in the hard chairs in the library to study for an exam while her roommates are watching a favorite TV show?
College is supposed to be a training ground for life.  Unfortunately, it’s a very expensive one, and if your child doesn’t have the maturity to do hard things, sending her off to college will not fix that.  “Baby steps” toward self-discipline could include having her begin to take charge of scarier tasks and more complex issues while still living at home: making her own appointments, taking classes from someone other than mom, meeting deadlines and fulfilling assignments.  Home education is great, but in the high school years (if not before) dealing with people outside the home is essential.  Simply getting a job will go a long way to building the skills and confidence that are so important in college.

Third: High-Level Reading
I recently led a discussion in which more than twenty teens each presented a book that they thought everyone should read for our book club, and yes, homeschoolers love Narnia and Lord of the Rings.  I love these books too, but if your teen’s reading never goes beyond this, he’ll have trouble in college.  Depending on what he majors in, he could have hundreds of pages per week of dense college texts to read, digest, and recall the major points of for class discussion and testing. 
To prepare for this, your child needs both quality and quantity: he needs to challenge himself by exploring new types of fiction and non-fiction–at times reading for speed and at other times for contemplation.  Study How to Read a Book by Adler and Van Doren as a primer on this topic.  Your child needs practice in marking up a text and taking notes on what he’s read.  Involving him in outside or online classes where these types of skills are required is a good way to start–and a safe place to fail if that is the outcome.  We want to have our failures before college if necessary, so that educational gaps will be identified and important lessons learned.

Fourth: Writing--Speed vs. Quality
The twenty-five minute essay test on the SAT has been the bane of my kids’ existence.  We don’t run our homeschool on a strict schedule (I’m not sure who does!) so my kids are used to taking their time on a piece of writing that they care about.  Sadly, on the SAT and afterwards in college, you often have to write about things you don’t care about, and write quickly because you have three other things also due the next day.  Traditionally-schooled students get lots of writing practice assigned–lots more than I’ve ever had my kids do–and start at a young age.  I tend to think that writing is the culmination of so many other skills that it is vulnerable to over-ambitious writing programs that extinguish the simple joy of self expression.  But there is certainly value to having kids begin writing essays in middle school, starting with fluffy topics and gradually becoming more serious, culminating with research papers.  Helping kids distinguish between a writing-for-quality paper vs. a writing-for-speed paper (an essay for your English class vs. a report for your geology class) is also a worthy topic of discussion in the high school years.

Fifth: Confidence in Math
Math is seen as a hurdle by many high school students–both on college entrance exams and in a college-prep high school curriculum.  The difference between facing higher math with anxiety or confidence begins much earlier, as we help our young children develop number sense, followed by operation sense, followed by function sense.  From the get-go, focus on math using things that can be seen and touched.  Leave working with symbols and the artificial conventions of math “problems” (like regrouping for subtraction) until the child has a concrete understanding of what is going on with quantities in the real world.  Building a logical brain is really fun: puzzles, games, pattern-making, etc.  My three year-old loves the DragonBox algebra app, and apart from fussing about the amount of screen time he does, I love that he’s already figuring out the logic behind balancing and simplifying equations.

If your child is struggling with math in the upper grades, it may be that he has learned to memorize the “steps” without understanding the logic behind them.  Even if a college entrance exam is looming, don’t be afraid to go back to math levels he is comfortable with, and have him work with manipulatives (you can buy rods with variables for algebra) or translate complex problems into simpler versions of the same operation so that he can visualize what is going on.  Using a program that takes a very different approach to math than what was previously used can also help those “Ah-hah” moments come along.  My son raised his SAT math score significantly after taking a few months to go through the Life of Fred program–he had previously studied math with Saxon, but Life of Fred helped him gain a wider perspective of math.

Good, Better, Best

Conventional wisdom says that success in college is directly related to academic skills, but I’ve found this to be off the mark.  Though the latter three points are essential, they are not to be emphasized at the expense of the former two.  Standardized testing measures what you know but not how motivated and hard-working you are, and in my opinion, this trumps academic knowledge in predicting college success.  And good grades won’t make up for a loss of spirituality when an immature soul makes bad choices because of the strong peer pressure, in and out of the classroom, to discard God in favor of worldly values.  As Jessie Wise noted in The Well-Trained Mind, one mom told her, after sending her daughter off to college, “I just spent forty thousand dollars to ruin my daughter’s life.”  Preparing our kids academically is good, making sure they are emotionally prepared to care for themselves while away from home is better, and making sure they face the world wearing the full armor of God is best.